Why Is Band Important in Education?


Introduction

I believe band is important because it has unique and intrinsic qualities that provide opportunities not present in other forms of music education.

In recent years, including in my former home city of Regina, SK, band programs have been subject to cuts by school boards that simply don’t seem to understand why band is important. Alongside their lack of understanding is another issue: those who should be advocating for band don’t always have a convincing answer to “why band?”

I worry greatly when I see ‘advocates’ using phrases where “band” could be replaced with “reading”, “chess club”, “shop”, “basketball” or countless other activities. This kind of ‘advocacy’ does not address the unique aspects of band.

When advocating for band, the reasons can’t only be external and secondary – our advocacy must address band’s uniqueness. We know that band is a safe space (so many of us realized that when it was our safe space), we know that music is an area where neurodivergent folks can share and express their gifts, and we have all seen the data on the secondary benefits that studying music has on cognitive development and academic achievement.

I wonder how many classrooms in Canada have a poster that exclaims “Do Sports! – The coordination you learn will help you with your clarinet playing” or “Math Is Important! – It will lead to better understanding of rhythms in band”?

Yet we find the opposite in band rooms across the country. Such posters may help parents understand the additional benefits their child may gain from playing in band, but they do not address the fundamental reason band should exist. These fundamental, intrinsic reasons are what decision-makers must hear. If our argument boils down to secondary benefits, they can point to other areas of education that offer the same benefits, and we have lost the argument.

Because I care deeply about band, and feel a responsibility as someone who earns part of my living from it to protect and advocate for it, I have outlined below why I believe band music and band music education are so important.

Power of Music → Power of Music Education → Why Instrumental Music? → Why Band?

Power of Music

At any one moment in music you can find beauty, love, empathy, compassion, joy, healing, and hope. To my mind there is nothing else in the world where you can find all of those things at the same time. Perhaps more than at any other point in my lifetime, the world needs those qualities now.

Power of Music Education

When people go into a music room, no matter what their age or background, they go in with something to say; something to express. They may not know it, but they are drawn to music as a form of expression and communication with others and with themselves.

Music education provides a space for creativity, expression, and belonging.

Why Instrumental Music?

Music education has many different facets, but as we head to junior high, the options tend to be consistent: band and choir (in certain places orchestra and guitar may also be offered).

I love choral music, I love singing, and I love choral music education – it is critically important for a great many reasons and has an equal place alongside instrumental music. But I believe instrumental music offers a freedom to explore and determine our own emotional narrative, as free as possible from other influences.

Where words may give us an emotional guide to follow, I believe that instrumental music gives anyone who experiences it the opportunity to explore their creative minds in a way that little else does.

The human experience is one of discovery, exploration, and curiosity. We came out of the cave, we learned to invent, art continues a journey of development, cures continue to be found for diseases: we are creative explorers – instrumental music is the platform that allows for that curiosity, perhaps more than any other.

Why Band?

So why band, specifically? I believe the answer lies in its ever-expanding repertoire. Whereas the orchestra has a substantial inherited repertoire (dating back hundreds of years) that is supplemented by new music, band music has a tradition of continually evolving repertoire.

Since the 1920 premiere of Holst’s ‘First Suite in Eb’ there has been rapid growth in the repertoire available to bands. This means band music can reflect our ever-changing society, constantly evolving to represent our communities and needs.

This expansion of repertoire has also led to an expansion of instruments and timbre, of ranges and articulations, leading to a broad palette that is full of colour and a wonderful platform for human expression.

Band, through its repertoire, is a vehicle for creative exploration. Members of a band are participating in an art form as the art form is expanding, contributing to the ever-widening exploration. Band is not perfect; it is a work in progress – but that in itself is part of the human condition.

In a society besieged by AI, something that gives the illusion of creating something new, and in an education system that increasingly measures what we can demonstrate, band gives us a place to create, interpret, collaborate, express something of our own – allowing us to explore and comment on the world around us.

Perhaps there has never been a more important time for band and its intrinsic qualities to be part of our education system.


Thanks to the following people for their editorial suggestions and support: Matt Abraham, Jason Caslor, Gill MacKay, Dylan Maddix, and Michelle Styles